Lexington Flag Case Update
Back in May, the Virginia SCV argued before the U.S. Fourth Circuit Court of Appeals to reinstate its case against the City of Lexington, Virginia, over the latter’s 2011 ordinance restricting use of its flagpoles to official city, state and national flags. On Friday, the Fourth Circuit declined to reinstate the case:
Although the First Amendment guarantees free speech in a public forum, it does not guarantee access to property simply because it is owned or controlled by the government,” the court wrote in its opinion, adding later: “It appears that the City experimented with private speakers displaying flags on the City’s standards, and that effort turned out to be troublesome. It was entitled, under the controlling principles, to alter that policy.Exactly right. You have a right to express your views; the government doesn’t have an obligation to provide a venue for them.
Meanwhile, Brandon Dorsey continues to whine that Lexington’s ordinance is comparable to Jim Crow segregation:
Dorsey said by that logic, it would be acceptable to close a public school or swimming pool to all people to keep black children out. “We wouldn’t let that stand today against a minority class,” he said.Sigh.
The SCV has two weeks to petititon the Fourth Circuit for an en banc review by the full court, or ninety days to file a petition to be heard by the Supremes.
__________
To save my friend Billy the trouble, here’s his comment from the linked article:
Thanks Andy – you’re the best ❤